"I'm a gonna pop a cap in yo... yo-what, class?"
"Yo ass, sir."
"Yes, and yo ass is a what-phrase?"
"A noun phrase, sir."
"Yes, well done, class."
This article from a Canadian online newspaper suggests that recent immigrants can pick up English through exposure to, and discussion of, rap music. I'm all in favour of novel approaches to grammar teaching and wouldn't dismiss this out of hand, even if the scene conjured up is a bit like the one at the start of this post, but on closer inspection the approach seems to be quite old-fashioned.
While the context is new - and even a touch funky - the grammatical approach appears rather prescriptive. We are told that Riaz asks each person to read a few lines from the song. He then walks them through a dissection of the lyrics that includes correcting the grammar".
It could just be a mistranslation between journalist and teacher, but correcting the grammar of hip hop lyrics seems like a bit of a sterile process. Fair enough, if differences between standard and non-standard forms are identified, then it might be an interesting exercise, but to "correct" grammar harks back to the 1950s. What is interesting however, and more positive, is the contextualisation of grammar in the reality of young people's language lives.
The possible concerns would relate more of the prospects and values which must have been understood by the individual to regard further. how to write a lit review
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteThe regarded provisions would possibly provide students all those reflective guides which must have been followed by them. Also See electronic store for best electronic
ReplyDeleteArticle spinning happens perpetually. The principal causes people perform this is often merely not concerning the most advantage of folks learning simply what the actual posts illustrate nevertheless to supply computer program promoting articles on the webpage.
ReplyDeleteArticle rewriting occurs constantly. The main leads to individuals carry out this could be basically not really in regards to the the majority of benefit of people understanding merely exactly what the particular try this articles demonstrate nonetheless to provide pc plan advertising content articles about the web page.
ReplyDeleteGood post, Text rewriting happens interminably. The essential causes individuals play out this is frequently only not concerning the most favorable position of people realizing basically what the real presents show by the by on supply PC program advancing articles on the website page.
ReplyDeleteExcellent post, The respected arrangements would conceivably give understudies each one of those intelligent aides which more likely than not been trained by them. Likewise, See electronic store for best electronic
ReplyDeleteThis hip hop strategy really amazed me.I think it went really successful in order to teach grammar.I found another link http://www.personalstatementwriters.com/ for learning writers.
ReplyDeleteLearning grammar through different ideas is really a great opportunity for the students. In this way we can read this blog and try to get better best ideas here quality documents. We should concentrate on the creativity of this blog. In this way we can perform best in the world of blogging.
ReplyDelete